Telecommunications Network Operators: 4Q19 Market Review

Telecommunications Network Operators: 4Q19 Market Review
Signs of recovery in 4Q19 after revenue decline for five straight quarters; imminent recession worries telcos
By Subramanian Venkatraman and Matt Walker

This market review provides a comprehensive assessment of the global telecommunications industry based on financial results through December 2019 (4Q19). The report tracks revenue, capex and employee for 133 individual telecommunications network operators (TNOs). For a sub-group of 50 large TNOs, the report also assesses labor cost, opex and operating profit trends. Our coverage timeframe spans 1Q11-4Q19 (36 quarters). The report’s format is Excel.

ABSTRACT

After a slump in revenue for five straight quarters, the global telecom industry staged a mild recovery. The industry’s 4Q19 revenues increased 1% YoY, as telcos diversified their services into IoT and media/content. The slight uptick in revenue was accompanied by a decline in capex and labor costs. Fourth quarter capex declined 3.2% from 4Q18. Annualized capex declined 1.6% to $297B in 4Q19, as debt concerns grew, and operators became keen on open networking, cloud partnerships, and asset spinoffs to cut capex. Telco spending on employees, or labor costs reached $291B in 4Q19 on an annualized basis, down 0.4% from the 4Q18 figure.

This month’s warning by the IMF about an imminent recession which could be worse than the 2007 global financial crisis has had telcos acting more cautiously. 5G deployments and investments in media will be slower. More layoffs are expected. Though not new for telcos, tighter margins will add to their grief.

Key findings:

1)  The long-term revenue growth of the telecom sector is 1.4% per year, on average, after adjusting for currency translation. In 4Q19, revenue was up 1.3% YoY on a fixed exchange rate basis. Actual revenue growth in 4Q19 increased 1% YoY to $465B. Both figures are consistent with the sector’s long-term growth average.

2) Even the modest growth currently achieved by the telecom sector requires high levels of capital investment in networks. The industry’s long-term capex to revenue ratio (capital intensity) is in the 16-17% range, on average (16.3% in 4Q19, annualized). Telcos also use M&A to expand their core business or move into adjacent markets; AT&T-Time Warner and Sprint-T-Mobile are just a few examples. The debt from such deals can drive up the operator’s interest payments and make it harder to fund capex, however. Such deals also inevitably come with layoffs.

3) On a revenue per employee (RPE) basis, the telco sector has been stagnant since 2011: the annualized figure was $362K that year, and the average figure for the last four quarters was $350K. Labor costs per employee, on an annualized basis were flat in 4Q19 compared to a year earlier at $56.1K.

4) Telcos employed 5.2M people in 4Q19, in line with recent quarters. Total headcount has not varied much since 2011 as telcos have focused instead on reshaping their workforce – cutting field engineers and installers, and hiring software developers, for instance. We expect employee totals to begin declining in the next 1-2 years. India alone may cut up to 100K employees in that timeframe, due to Jio’s consolidation & BSNL reforms.

5) The M&A climate remains strong for the sector in 2020. Many telcos see their core markets declining, and are buying their way into other markets while also streamlining their asset base. Noteworthy recent deals include the recent merger of T-Mobile and Sprint, Comcast’s acquisition of Sky, the merger of Vodafone India and Idea Cellular; and Vodafone’s $18B acquisition of Liberty Global’s Germany and Eastern Europe cable and broadband assets. However, after the M&A deal paperwork is signed, integrating operations and actually achieving synergies continues to be a challenge for telcos. Managing the debt from these acquisitions is just as hard, as AT&T and others are discovering.

6) Telco industry operating margins have been stable for the last 11 quarters, averaging around 13.6%, on an annualized basis. Single quarter operating margins increased in 4Q19, to 13.3% from 11.1% in 4Q18. The rise in margins is due to a fall in opex which declined by 1.4% in 4Q19 versus 4Q18.

Impact of the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020: Lower handset and ad revenue, delayed 5G rollout

With the world reeling under the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic, most industries are feeling the heat of this unprecedented situation. Businesses worldwide are faced with a recessionary climate and telcos are no exception. The impact of the pandemic will likely be felt across their operations.

The telecom sector faces supply chain risks, and handset/device revenue will take a hit due to reduced production of 5G smartphones and handset components.

Lower consumer spending due to lockdown in most countries and a rise in defaults on financed handset plans will also hurt revenue generation. On the enterprise side, wireline operations could see revenue declines accelerate due to lower corporate spending and higher unemployment. Telcos with significant media and advertising segments will see revenue declines due to suspension of upcoming sporting events. Examples include Telefonica, BT Altice and AT&T.

In European countries, 5G auctions anytime in the next several months are next to impossible amid the COVID-19 pandemic; France has already postponed an auction. This will directly affect any near-term sales prospects for the telcos. Looking ahead, TNOs are likely to revisit their capex budgets and slash spending on 5G.

Amid all the bad news, the increase in data traffic and higher demand for virtual private network (VPN) capacity could offer some relief for the operators. Although not immediately, operators are likely to migrate some users in the consumer segment to more premium packages and make attempts to monetize the rise in data traffic.

Table Of Contents

  1. Abstract
  2. Market snapshot
  3. Market overview
  4. Key stats through 4Q19
  5. Operator rankings
  6. Single-company drilldowns
  7. Revenue and capex by country
  8. TNO-133: Revenue, capex and headcount for 133 TNOs
  9. TNO-50: Cost breakdowns for 50 large TNOs
  10. Raw Data
  11. Subs & traffic
  12. Exchange rates
  13. About (including methodology)

Figure & Charts

1) TNOs: Annualized revenue ($M) and YoY growth (%), 4Q14-4Q19
2) TNOs: Annualized capex ($M) and capital intensity (%), 4Q14-4Q19
3) Labor cost/revenue (%), 2019
4) Labor cost and labor cost per employee, 2019 YoY change (%)
5) Change in annualized operating margins (YoY percentage point difference 4Q13-4Q19)
6) Local currency value vs. US$ (QoQ change)
7) Top 20 share of the market, 4Q19
8) Top 20 TNOs by total capex, 4Q19
9) Top 20 TNOs by total revenue, 4Q19
10) TNOs: YoY growth in single quarter revenues
11) TNOs: Annualized capital intensity, 4Q11-4Q19
12) TNOs: Revenue and RPE, annualized 4Q14-4Q19
13) TNOs: Capex and capital intensity (annualized), 4Q14-4Q19
14) TNOs: Total headcount trends, 4Q11-4Q19
15) TNOs: Revenue and RPE trends, 2011-19
16) TNOs: Capex and capital intensity, 2011-19 ($ Mn)
17) TNOs: Capex and capital intensity, 4Q14-4Q19 ($ Mn)
18) TNOs: Revenue and RPE trends, 4Q14-4Q19
19) Top 40 TNOs by total opex, 4Q19
20) Top 40 TNOs by labor costs, 4Q19

Coverage

Countries
Argentina Finland Japan Norway Taiwan
Australia France Kenya Oman Thailand
Austria Germany Kuwait Philippines Turkey
Bahrain Hong Kong Luxembourg Poland UAE
Brazil India Malaysia Qatar UK
Canada Indonesia Mexico Russia USA
Chile Israel Morocco South Korea
China Italy Singapore Spain
Denmark Netherlands South Africa Sweden
Egypt New Zealand Saudi Arabia Switzerland

 

Companies
Altice USA Advanced Info Service (AIS) A1 Telekom Austria Batelco Oi
America Movil Axiata Altice Europe Bezeq Israel Quebecor Telecommunications
AT&T Bharti Airtel Limited Bouygues Telecom Cellcom Israel Rogers
Axtel BSNL BT Cell C Sasktel
BCE China Mobile Com Hem Holding AB Du Shaw Communications
Cable ONE, Inc. China Telecom Cyfrowy Polsat Etisalat Sprint
Cablevision China Unicom Deutsche Telekom Maroc Telecom SureWest Communications
CenturyLink Chunghwa Telecom Digi Communications MTN Group TDS
Cequel Communications CK Hutchison DNA Ltd. Omantel Telecom Argentina
Charter Communications DEN Networks Limited EE Ooredoo Telus
Cincinatti Bell Dish TV India Limited Elisa Safaricom Limited Time Warner
Clearwire Far EasTone Telecommunications Co., Ltd. Iliad SA STC (Saudi Telecom) Time Warner Cable
Cogeco Globe Telecom KPN Telecom Egypt Verizon
Comcast Hathway Cable & Datacom Limited Liberty Global Telkom SA Windstream
Consolidated Communications Idea Cellular Limited Megafon Zain Singtel
DirecTV KDDI Mobile Telesystems Zain KSA SITI Networks Limited
Dish Network KT Corporation Orange Telia SK Telecom
Entel LG Uplus Proximus Veon SmarTone
Fairpoint Communications M1 Rostelecom Virgin Media SoftBank
Frontier Communications Maxis Berhad Sky plc Vivendi Spark New Zealand Limited
Grupo Clarin MTNL Swisscom Vodafone StarHub
Grupo Televisa NTT TDC Wind Tre Taiwan Mobile
Leap Wireless PCCW Tele2 AB Telstra Tata Communications Limited
Manitoba Telecom Services PLDT Telecom Italia Thaicom Tata Teleservices
MetroPCS Communications Reliance Communications Limited Telefonica TPG Telecom Limited Telekom Malaysia Berhad
Millicom Reliance Jio Telenor True Corp Telkom Indonesia
Turkcell Vodafone Idea Limited Turk Telekom

 

Visuals

Related reports

Webscale Network Operators: 4Q19 Market Review

By Arun Menon and Matt Walker On April 10, 2020 MTN Consulting’s 4Q19 WNO Market Review analyzes the network infrastructure spending and financial position of webscale network ope... read more

Telecom’s biggest vendors – 3Q19 edition

By Matt Walker On December 20, 2019 Objective The goal of this report series is to equip telecom industry decision-makers with a comprehensive view of spending trends and vendor market power in their indust... read more