Operators feel the pinch of rising labor costsNarola
Global telecom operators are facing a cost crunch. Based on MTN Consulting’s analysis, annualized operating profit margins have fallen for five straight quarters, from 13.7% in 2Q17 to 12.7% in 3Q18. This profit dip comes during strong economic times; a recession would make this far worse. Further, telcos need cash to fund their 5G migrations and to pursue M&A opportunities. As the pressure to improve profitability rises, telcos are looking to reduce their labor costs.
Labor costs average over 15% of revenues
For the 12 months ended Sept. 2018, telecom network operator (TNO) capex was $304B, or 16.5% of revenues. This is the single biggest component of costs for most TNOs. Labor costs come in a bit lower at 15.3% of revenues, based on an MTN Consulting analysis of 40 large operators. As TNOs reshape their workforces to meet new requirements – hiring software developers, retaining fewer field engineers – they are getting serious about managing their labor costs more smartly.
Across the globe, TNOs pursue a wide range of business strategies and face a range of relative input costs. Labor costs vary widely as a share of total. Generally, the higher the GDP per capita, the more salient is the issue of labor costs. Also, fixed operators tend to have more employees per subscriber, or per dollar of revenue, than their mobile counterparts. As Figure 1 below shows, mobile operators in emerging markets have the lowest labor cost burdens, in general: Bharti Airtel, Idea Cellular, the MTN Group, Axiata.
Every rule has exceptions, though. Japan-based KDDI, an integrated (fixed-mobile) TNO in a high-income market, reports labor costs totalling just 8% of revenues. In this case, KDDI has abnormally high non-staff costs, in particular sales commission costs and handset expenses: these two totalled $11.7B in FY2018, about 3x the level of staff costs ($3.8B).
Labor cost pressures are rising
Our analysis of 2011-17 finds that many telecom operators are already struggling with labor costs. Some operators, such as BSNL and MTNL (not shown in figure), face labor costs in excess of 50% of revenues. These two operators represent an extreme example of a problem many other TNOs face: laws and union agreements restricting their hiring and firing. These are good things for social welfare, but do pose challenges for telcos facing competitors with more nimble workforces. More commonly, TNO labor costs are in the 10-20% range of revenues. When measured on a per-employee basis, the global average for labor costs in 3Q18 was $57,800 per year, slightly up from the year earlier.
Some of the reasons behind recent TNO labor cost growth include: surge in wages or headcount, rise in pension costs, and in some cases, inflationary pressures.
To substantiate this point, let’s look at the recent labor cost data for a few sample telcos:
- China Mobile and China Unicom saw a drop in their headcount but their labor costs for 2017 surged by 5% and 12%, respectively. The surge could be attributable to the operators’ strategy to boost the sales and productivity of their broadband business and the consequent increase in compensation of its front-line staff.
- Despite a 3% drop in headcount, labor costs for Canada-based Rogers increased by 4%. This increase was due to high salaries and pensions paid to the players of Toronto Blue Jays (Canada’s only Major League Baseball team owned by Rogers) and higher TSC merchandise costs. Likewise, BCE’s labor cost was up 5% YoY as its headcount increased by 7% – post the integration of MTS employees.
- SK Telecom’s labor cost was up 8% YoY in 2017; however, this arose from SKTs formation of a newly formed subsidiary “Home & Service”, in effect insourcing a service which was earlier outsourced to third party vendors. Behind the 8% cost increase is an 18.4% increase in headcount.
Telcos often rely on early retirement plans or come up with outsourcing options to save on their labor costs. Here are recent developments at a few large telcos that exemplify this:
- In the case of Deutsche Telekom, it introduced an early retirement plan in 2017 for its civil servants which resulted in a 4% YoY decline in its labor costs, compared to revenues, which grew 4.6%” in 2017.
- In September 2018, Verizon offered a voluntary severance package (VSP) to about 44,000 employees – and it also struck a $700 Mn deal with India based Infosys to outsource over 2,500 IT staff or more.
- Loss making Indian PSUs –BSNL and MTNL – spent close to 56% and 94% of their revenue toward labor costs in 2017. Contrary to other private players such as Airtel and Idea – which spent only 5% and 6% of its revenues towards staff costs. BSNL and MTNL have a headcount of 185,000 and 25,000, respectively, which makes cutting staff a pressing need for these operators. Both companies have had to resort to voluntary retirement scheme (VRS) to achieve a break-even point. A VRS scheme for MTNL was always on the cards, especially with its huge debt burden (INR170 Bn, approx. US$2.5B).
Automation leading to fewer jobs in Europe
Telecom operators are increasingly using automation, artificial intelligence (AI), and a range of other technologies to drive efficiency gains. Recent trends suggest that most operators headquartered in Europe are either on a hiring freeze or on a lay-off spree (figure, below).
The below developments at some of the leading European telcos exemplify this trend.
- Telecom Italia reduced its headcount by 1,800 in 2017 – about 3% of its total employees. The operator further plans to downsize its staff by 4,500. Technology investments will make this possible. Under a new plan named ‘DigiTIM’ – Telecom Italia aims to reduce human-operated interactions” by 30% and get 85% of its customers to use self-care apps. It also partnered with Microsoft to use its AI technology to develop chatbots.
- Similarly, Telefonica reduced its headcount by 5.1% in 2017, as it launched its own AI-powered digital assistant ‘Aura’ to improve customer service. This was accompanied by an 8% drop in the average labor cost per employee, to $62,075.
- Deutsche Telekom (DT) also plans to restructure its staff and prioritize automation and digitalisation. The company claims these investments will lead to a 1.5B Euros annual reduction in annual “indirect costs.
However, the telco job market is not all about managing decline. Many operators are employing automation and digitalisation and retraining and reskilling their workforce at the same time. 1According to Ernst & Young’s 2018 Global Capital Confidence Barometer, about 57% of the surveyed executives see AI and automation as the most prominent technologies on their boardroom agenda.
Rising M&A, shrinking employee numbers
M&A activity is a part of life for telecom network operators. While many large deals have already been closed in recent years, M&A will continue to reshape the market, blurring the lines between TNOs, webscale, carrier-neutral, media, and other network operators. Given competitive pressures and the need to improve margins, we expect M&A in telecom to remain vigorous. According to Ernst & Young’s 2018 Global Capital Confidence Barometer, there is an increased appetite for M&A in the near term, with 59% of interviewed telecom executives intending to pursue M&A in the next 12 months.
Acquisitions can have a big impact on the average cost of the TNO employee. When BT acquired EE, its average employee costs dropped dramatically. Acquisitions of cable or other fixed operators by mobile TNOs, by contrast, tend to drive labor costs upwards.
M&A deals often result in workforce redundancies as there is a natural overlap of jobs. For example, AT&T has a long history of cutting jobs as part of its M&A evolution. Post its DirecTV acquisition in 2015, AT&T’s headcount reduced from 281,450 in 2015 to 254,000 in 2017. Though no major restructuring has been announced so far, AT&T’s plans to build its own 5G network and its recent purchase of Time Warner could mean that AT&T employees will soon feel the heat.
CenturyLink is following a similar path – as it confirms reduction of 2% of its headcount post its acquisition of Level 3 Communications. In May 2018, CenturyLink’s spokesman Mark Molzen said that
“The combination of two large companies also creates redundant positions that must be addressed to remain competitive. In addition, as part of our ongoing efforts to deliver high levels of customer service, we are implementing best practices and increasing automation. As a result of these two factors, we are reducing our workforce by approximately 2 percent.”
The largest labor union in the US telecom sector, Communications Workers of America (CWA), estimates that the much-awaited merger of T-Mobile and Sprint could potentially result in huge headcount reductions – about 28,000 jobs. The CWA estimate conflicts with official company estimates, which – perhaps not surprisingly – claim the merger would create new jobs. This conflict will continue.
In India, the telecom labor market is in a gloomy state as consolidation has become the norm and job losses are mounting. As per a report published by CIEL HR Service, job losses could reach up to 90,000 by 2018. The recent Vodafone and Idea merger, which already cut 5,000 employees, could lay off 2,500 more people in the next few months, as part of realizing its targeted $10 billion “synergy benefits” from the merger. Similarly, post Airtel’s merger with Telenor India, Airtel said only 50% of the latter’s employees would still be employed by the merged entity.
As top-line growth remains low, and new capex requirements are on the way, operators are compelled to reduce their labor costs. To achieve this, we expect telcos to use the tools of both AI and M&A.
Cover image: Shutterstock